
This year's American Idol Top 11 contestants headed on the annual AI tour.
A couple of weeks ago, the annual American Idols Live! Tour rolled into San Jose, and after attending my first show during season 8, I sort of made it an unofficial tradition to attend every year. Unlike previous years, the show was not set up in a countdown format, where contestant performed in the order they were eliminated, but rather it was all mixed up, allowing for more solos and group numbers. The girls kicked off the show with a performance of Lady Gaga’s Born This Way, which led to a revolving door of solos, duets, and group performances. The show was basically split into two parts: The Pia Toscano Show (feat. Stefano Langone) and The Country Bears Jamboree. However, I’ll be commenting on them in the order they were eliminated.
Thia Megia:

Thia Megia was pleasant. Her frilly dresses and quiet demeanor really made her go unnoticed though. Her solo performance of the Selena Gomez, Who Says was her only solo song. It was nice, but outside of that, it was just there. While she wasn’t bad in her performance or in her group parts, there wasn’t much that made her stand out.
Naima Adedapo:

Naima Adedapo was eliminated the same week as Thia Megia. She deserved to stay on the show longer, and her performances proved that. Her solo performance of Jennifer Lopez’s On The Floor was one of the most fun moments of the show. She was a burst of energy and I wish she had more numbers to perform in. Her On the Floor performance was probably the highlight of the show’s first half.
Pia Toscano:

The people who put together the Idol tour want to remind you that Pia is good. Really really good. She was put in practically every number of the tour, she opened up the show, and she even got to sing her first post-Idol single (to my knowledge, the first time it had happened). She can sing the hell out of a ballad and can really stand in one place and really wave her arm. Her voice is great, but there were moments in her performance where it seemed as if it kind of just dragged on. However, she looked great and could really belt out a tune.
Paul McDonald:

Paul McDonald was basically a fun, drunk uncle performing. His Maggie Mae performance helped pump the crowd up and was a delight. However, his appearance was short, so there was nothing really more to it. It was fun and light.
Stefano Langone:

Stefano Langone thinks he’s awesome. From his tweets proclaiming something like he’s better than Bruno Mars to saying that he’ll be winning Grammys next year, he’s a little big for his britches. While he may talk the talk, he really sounds like a generic Latin singer. That doesn’t mean he sounds bad, but if there really isn’t anything to make him standout from any other singer with Latin ~flair. His performances showed off his bloated ego, which made them border on the ridiculous side, especially when he ended his set by stripping his shirt off.
Casey Abrams:

On the show, Casey was hit and miss for me. Sometimes I liked him, but others he creeped me out. Thankfully, for the tour rendition of Idol, it consisted more of me liking him. Though at one point he did get a little creepy, it was towards the end of his set. The upright bass he brought out for his rendition of Santana and Rob Thomas’ Smooth gave it a moody and new feel, which was really enjoyable.
Jacob Lusk:

Jacob Lusk could really belt, and he showed it, especially with the two R&B songs he chose to perform. They were upbeat and happy numbers, which really kept the show going. His happiness and joy shone through and he gave a really fun performance.
James Durbin:

James was such a mixed bag. It was his hometown show, so there was a lot of support for him in the audience. He started off strong too. His first song, Guns N Roses Sweet Child O’ Mine was rousing opener and it seemed as if everyone was in to it. It was a perfect choice to kick of his performance. Things took a 180 right after, with Muse’s Uprising. Although he would like to think he was hitting amazing high notes, he was really producing cringe-inducing shrills. Despite his shrieks, he kept up his energy throughout his performances, but that wasn’t enough to make up for his ear-splitting scream.
Haley Reinhart:

Perhaps the best of the night, Haley’s slinky, sexy set was expertly sung. Her growly voice worked perfectly for her reprises of House of the Rising Sun and Bennie and the Jets. House started off acapella and it was chill-inducing. Bennie, in turn, was a fun jazzy number. With her two songs, Haley was, for me, the best performer of the night and triumphantly showed that the judges bashing her week after week were basically wrong.
Lauren Alaina:

My journey with Lauren on the show was strange. When she first was introduced I quite liked her, but as it went on, I got annoyed with how she was portrayed. However, as the show started coming to a close, I started liking her again. On tour, she did what she probably did best: pop-tinged country music, and she really sold it. I had forgotten how strong her voice was and her live performances really showed it off.
Scotty McCreery:

Scotty McCreery, the good-ole-boy from the South that sang about Jesus and 9/11 ultimately took home the American Idol title. Every week, he took country songs and always did them well. His tour choices were no different. Performances like Gone were cheesy, wholesome fun, while the back to back ballads kind of dragged his set down a bit. His coronation song, I Love You This Big was sappy and cheesy, which pretty much made it kind of funny to sit through. Despite dragging at times, his voice was always clear and he sounded great, and he had the shrieking girls eating out of his hand.
This Could Have Been Better:
- The Order: Maybe it was because I was used to the countdown format, where the contestants perform in the order they were eliminated, but the random group performances inter-cut with solo sets was strange to me. I liked the countdown version because it was able to highlight each contestant more.
- James Durbin: Uprising was just not a good choice for him.
- The Pia Toscano Show (feat. Stefano Langone): We get it! Pia is good. However, the whole first half of the show was pretty much dedicated to her and Stefano. It would’ve been nice to see more of the other contestants.
Highlights:
- Haley Reinhart: To me, Haley was the performance of the night. She sounded flawless and her jazzy, slinky set was the perfect thing to show that Randy and J.Lo’s constant attacks were completely unwarranted.
- Naima Adedapo: I was blown away by the 10th (or 11th) place finisher. Her performance of Jennifer Lopez’s On the Floor was a fun, energetic treat. It was a shame that she was on stage for so little.
- Baby Lock Dem Doors: Finally hearing Scotty McCreery perform his go-to song, Your Man (aka Baby Lock Dem Doors) was worth the price of admission.
Overall: The show’s mixed up order proved to be a new way to see the show. It gave it more of a variety show feel while highlighting some of the contestants more than others. Like past Idol shows, it was a good mix of different genres that had something for everyone. Even though each contestant gave their best on stage, the night belonged to third place finisher, Haley Reinhart.
Setlist:
- Born This Way (Naima, Thia, Haley, Lauren, and Pia)
- Empire State of Mind (Pia)
- California King Bed (Pia & Stefano)
- Maggie Mae (Paul McDonald)
- Who Says (Thia Megia)
- Tight Rope (Naima, Thia, Haley, and Pia)
- Grenade (Stefano)
- DJ Got Us Falling in Love (Stefano w/ Naima, Thia, Haley, and Pia on backing vocals)
- Animal (Paul, Jacob, Casey, Stefano, & James)
- On the Floor (Naima)
- This Time (Pia)
- Firework (Pia, Lauren, & Thia)
- Smooth (Casey)
- Moanin’ (Casey & Haley)
- Harder to Breathe (Casey)
- Forget You (All, except Scotty)
- Flat On the Floor (Lauren)
- Like My Mother Does (Lauren)
- If I Die Young (Lauren w/ Stefano, Thia, & Haley on backing vocals)
- Sweet Child o’ Mine (James)
- Uprising (James)
- Never Too Much (Jacob)
- You’re All I Need To Get By (Jacob w/ Naima, Stefano, & Pia on backing vocals)
- The House of the Rising Sun (Haley)
- Bennie & The Jets (Haley)
- Your Man (Scotty)
- Are You Gonna Kiss Me or Not (Scotty)
- I Love You This Big (Scotty)
- When You Say Nothing At All (Scotty & Lauren)
- Gone (Scotty)
- Here I Go Again (James & Lauren)/Faithfully (Casey, Paul, & Haley)/Walk This Way (Naima, Jacob, Stefano, & Thia)/Any Way You Want It/Touchin’, Kissin’, & Squeezin’ (All)